Raymond
2012-01-15 19:21:56 UTC
Posner's Rear Guards
Case Closed : The author, Gerald Posner, tells us why the alleged
assassin, Lee Oswald, left the TSBD by way of the front door of the
building, since he allegedly used the rear stairs to exit the sixth
floor after the shooting. Posner says, " His choice to leave by the
front door was propitious. Immediately after the shots , two
construction workers, George Rackley and James Romack, volunteered to
help the police by keeping a watch on the rear exit. During the five
minutes they were there, before they were replaced by police units, no
one left from that exit. The building's front was not covered for at
least ten minutes, and possibly longer."
PP.255-256.
This kind of reaching to hopefully prove his point is a disgrace. The
testimony of the two men must be read to appreciate Posner's search
for convincing evidence. Either Posner did not read the testimony of
Romak and Rackley, or the author feels that his audience will not
check his source notes and the original and complete testimony of the
witnesses.
First, the two men were not construction workers. George Rackley Sr.
was a laborer for the
Coordinated Railroad Co. When asked by David Belin, Assistant Counsel
of the President's Commission, what his job was, Rackley responded, "
I unload trailers."
Further testimony from the interview on April 6, 1964:
Mr. Belin: How old are you?
Mr. Rakley: I am 60.
When asked where Rackley's place of employment was located in
relation to than TSBD, Rackley answered: " It is on Ross and Market
Street, about TWO BLOCKS FROM THE COURTHOUSE."
Mr. Belin: Now where is that in relation to the corner of Elm and
Houston?
Mr. Rackley: Well, it is up on Ross. Two blocks north is where
our
place is.
Mr. Belin:Your place is two blocks north of the corner of Elm and
Houston?
Mr. Rackley: Yes, sir.
Mr. Belin: You work indoors or outdoors?
Mr. Rackley: Just all over town.
Mr. Belin: Just all over town?
Mr. Rackley: Yes, sir.
Mr. Belin: Did you see the President's motorcade at all on that
day?
Mr. Rackley: No, sir: I didn't.
Mr. Belin: What did you see?
Mr. Rackley: I didn't practically see anything.
Mr. belin: Did you hear the sounds that sounded like firecrackers
or shots at all?
Mr. Rackley: No, sir.
Mr. Belin: About how far would you have been from the northeast
corner of the TSBD?
Mr. Rackley: I would say right at a block.
Mr. Belin:Did you see anything in the parade?
Mr. Rackey: The only thing- I told the guy, he was down there, the
only thing that I saw that looked suspicious to me was something like
a hundred pigeons flew up like you shot them, and I noticed that, but
I never heard no shots.
Mr. Belin: Where did you see them fly from?
Mr. Rackley; From over the top of the building.
Mr. Belin: Which building? The School Book Depository or over on the
other side?
Mr. Rackley: The Trinity Building.
Mr. Belin; Which building did they fly off of?
Mr. Rackley: I wasn't looking, I just seen they all flew together.
Posner's other witness, James Elbert Romack, who was working with
Rackley also testified on the same day. His complete testimony must be
read to understand that Posner would have been better served by not
mentioning the rear door of the TSBD.
Romack, like Rackley, worked for Coordinating Transportation Co. When
asked by Belin what he did, Romack answered: "Driving mostly your big
van trailer-truck and bobtail trucks and pickup and delivery
service."
Belin: Did you see any employees walk up the back way?
Romack: There was two other gentlemen which I never said anything
about, that taken over. They were FBI or something standing right here
at the very entrance, and just stood there.
Romack goes on to explain that he went on home after the confusion.
Belin: Did you ever contact the FBI?
Romack: Yes, sir.
Belin: When did you do that ?
Romack: It was on Saturday night after I got home from work.
Belin: What month was that?
Romack: It was this past month. ( March 1964, 4 months after
11-22-63 ).
Belin: You mean March?
Romack: Right. ----
6 H 277-284.
Posner says that no one left by the back door-the back of the
building was sealed. What about it? Forest Sorrels, SA of the Secret
Service, and in the lead car of the motorcade, went to Parkland
Hospital with the President's limousine. After 20 minutes, he returned
to Dealey Plaza. Here is part of his testimony:
Sorrels: ... And upon arrival at the Book Store, we pulled up on
the side, and I went in the back door.
Stern: Just a minute. had you heard any mention of the Book
Depository on a police broadcast as you drove to the hospital?
Sorrels: No, I never heard anything.
Stern: And, at that point, you were not certain that the shots
came from the Book Depository?
Sorrels: No, I didn't know at the time... And upon arrival at the
Book Depository, I went in the back door.
Sorrels then tells about meeting a colored man on the loading dock who
was looking off in a distance, " I don't think he knew what
happened."
Stern: There was no policeman stationed at the loading platform when
you came up?
Sorrels: I did not see one, no sir.
Stern: And you were able to enter the building without identifying
yourself?
Sorrels: Yes, sir. 7 H 347-348.
On March 19, 1964, James Richard Worrell Jr., told the Commission
that he had seen a man rush out of the back door of the TSBD and run
out of sight.
Posner is selective using Worrell's testimony. The nineteen year old
student also told the Commission that he actually saw the rifle fire.
This testimony, unlike the rear door testimony was useful to Posner's
argument, so he used it. That someone was seen rushing from the rear
door hinders Posner's cause, so he omits that part of Worrell's
testimony. The young man, who was killed in a motorcycle accident on
Nov. 5, 1966, told the Commission in 1964, that the man he saw come
out of the rear door "was fast moving on."
Another witness, Amos Euins, testified that he heard a witness tell a
policeman that he had "seen a man run out the back" and " the man had
some kind of bald spot on his head." 2 H 205-208.
Could the witness that Euins described have been Worrell? No, because
Worrell said nothing about his observation of the "running man" until
the next day, so someone else reported that they had seen a man,
clearly not Oswald, run out of the rear door of the TSBD. No attempt
was made to locate the unknown witness described by Amos Euins.
"Case Closed?" Maybe not.
Case Closed : The author, Gerald Posner, tells us why the alleged
assassin, Lee Oswald, left the TSBD by way of the front door of the
building, since he allegedly used the rear stairs to exit the sixth
floor after the shooting. Posner says, " His choice to leave by the
front door was propitious. Immediately after the shots , two
construction workers, George Rackley and James Romack, volunteered to
help the police by keeping a watch on the rear exit. During the five
minutes they were there, before they were replaced by police units, no
one left from that exit. The building's front was not covered for at
least ten minutes, and possibly longer."
PP.255-256.
This kind of reaching to hopefully prove his point is a disgrace. The
testimony of the two men must be read to appreciate Posner's search
for convincing evidence. Either Posner did not read the testimony of
Romak and Rackley, or the author feels that his audience will not
check his source notes and the original and complete testimony of the
witnesses.
First, the two men were not construction workers. George Rackley Sr.
was a laborer for the
Coordinated Railroad Co. When asked by David Belin, Assistant Counsel
of the President's Commission, what his job was, Rackley responded, "
I unload trailers."
Further testimony from the interview on April 6, 1964:
Mr. Belin: How old are you?
Mr. Rakley: I am 60.
When asked where Rackley's place of employment was located in
relation to than TSBD, Rackley answered: " It is on Ross and Market
Street, about TWO BLOCKS FROM THE COURTHOUSE."
Mr. Belin: Now where is that in relation to the corner of Elm and
Houston?
Mr. Rackley: Well, it is up on Ross. Two blocks north is where
our
place is.
Mr. Belin:Your place is two blocks north of the corner of Elm and
Houston?
Mr. Rackley: Yes, sir.
Mr. Belin: You work indoors or outdoors?
Mr. Rackley: Just all over town.
Mr. Belin: Just all over town?
Mr. Rackley: Yes, sir.
Mr. Belin: Did you see the President's motorcade at all on that
day?
Mr. Rackley: No, sir: I didn't.
Mr. Belin: What did you see?
Mr. Rackley: I didn't practically see anything.
Mr. belin: Did you hear the sounds that sounded like firecrackers
or shots at all?
Mr. Rackley: No, sir.
Mr. Belin: About how far would you have been from the northeast
corner of the TSBD?
Mr. Rackley: I would say right at a block.
Mr. Belin:Did you see anything in the parade?
Mr. Rackey: The only thing- I told the guy, he was down there, the
only thing that I saw that looked suspicious to me was something like
a hundred pigeons flew up like you shot them, and I noticed that, but
I never heard no shots.
Mr. Belin: Where did you see them fly from?
Mr. Rackley; From over the top of the building.
Mr. Belin: Which building? The School Book Depository or over on the
other side?
Mr. Rackley: The Trinity Building.
Mr. Belin; Which building did they fly off of?
Mr. Rackley: I wasn't looking, I just seen they all flew together.
Posner's other witness, James Elbert Romack, who was working with
Rackley also testified on the same day. His complete testimony must be
read to understand that Posner would have been better served by not
mentioning the rear door of the TSBD.
Romack, like Rackley, worked for Coordinating Transportation Co. When
asked by Belin what he did, Romack answered: "Driving mostly your big
van trailer-truck and bobtail trucks and pickup and delivery
service."
Belin: Did you see any employees walk up the back way?
Romack: There was two other gentlemen which I never said anything
about, that taken over. They were FBI or something standing right here
at the very entrance, and just stood there.
Romack goes on to explain that he went on home after the confusion.
Belin: Did you ever contact the FBI?
Romack: Yes, sir.
Belin: When did you do that ?
Romack: It was on Saturday night after I got home from work.
Belin: What month was that?
Romack: It was this past month. ( March 1964, 4 months after
11-22-63 ).
Belin: You mean March?
Romack: Right. ----
6 H 277-284.
Posner says that no one left by the back door-the back of the
building was sealed. What about it? Forest Sorrels, SA of the Secret
Service, and in the lead car of the motorcade, went to Parkland
Hospital with the President's limousine. After 20 minutes, he returned
to Dealey Plaza. Here is part of his testimony:
Sorrels: ... And upon arrival at the Book Store, we pulled up on
the side, and I went in the back door.
Stern: Just a minute. had you heard any mention of the Book
Depository on a police broadcast as you drove to the hospital?
Sorrels: No, I never heard anything.
Stern: And, at that point, you were not certain that the shots
came from the Book Depository?
Sorrels: No, I didn't know at the time... And upon arrival at the
Book Depository, I went in the back door.
Sorrels then tells about meeting a colored man on the loading dock who
was looking off in a distance, " I don't think he knew what
happened."
Stern: There was no policeman stationed at the loading platform when
you came up?
Sorrels: I did not see one, no sir.
Stern: And you were able to enter the building without identifying
yourself?
Sorrels: Yes, sir. 7 H 347-348.
On March 19, 1964, James Richard Worrell Jr., told the Commission
that he had seen a man rush out of the back door of the TSBD and run
out of sight.
Posner is selective using Worrell's testimony. The nineteen year old
student also told the Commission that he actually saw the rifle fire.
This testimony, unlike the rear door testimony was useful to Posner's
argument, so he used it. That someone was seen rushing from the rear
door hinders Posner's cause, so he omits that part of Worrell's
testimony. The young man, who was killed in a motorcycle accident on
Nov. 5, 1966, told the Commission in 1964, that the man he saw come
out of the rear door "was fast moving on."
Another witness, Amos Euins, testified that he heard a witness tell a
policeman that he had "seen a man run out the back" and " the man had
some kind of bald spot on his head." 2 H 205-208.
Could the witness that Euins described have been Worrell? No, because
Worrell said nothing about his observation of the "running man" until
the next day, so someone else reported that they had seen a man,
clearly not Oswald, run out of the rear door of the TSBD. No attempt
was made to locate the unknown witness described by Amos Euins.
"Case Closed?" Maybe not.