Damien Sullivan
2007-01-31 00:10:32 UTC
John Ford wrote two Star Trek novels that I know of, both fairly famous
among fans. One, _How Much For the Planet_ is loved by some as clever
comedy and loathed by others as character-abusing claptrap. The other,
_The Final Reflection_, is I think generally admired as a depiction of
an alien culture[1].
But there's a common element I had not noticed before[2]. In HMftP, the
colonists of Direidi engage in Plan C ("for Comedy"), an attempt to make
Federation and Klingon ambassadors look very silly. This is the main
bulk of the book, though I forget if the point was to embarrass them
into playing nice on the spot, or to generate blackmail material.
In tFR, Captain Krenn figures out the human concept of "silly" and uses
it to his advantage, by being one unarmed polite Klingon where the
Federation expected a snarling dangerous horde. This is a small part of
the book, or perhaps more accurately a quiet part of the book, but a
significant one.
Anyway, I've read both books multiple times, but just noticed that on
the last re-read of tFR. I figured I'd share.
-xx- Damien X-)
[1] Though the space combat scenes have all the realism of, well, a very
unrealistic thing.
[2] There's a second element in common -- and distinct from most other
Star Trek novels or shows in any series. They take the Organian Peace
Treaty seriously; the lightbulbs are still on the job.
among fans. One, _How Much For the Planet_ is loved by some as clever
comedy and loathed by others as character-abusing claptrap. The other,
_The Final Reflection_, is I think generally admired as a depiction of
an alien culture[1].
But there's a common element I had not noticed before[2]. In HMftP, the
colonists of Direidi engage in Plan C ("for Comedy"), an attempt to make
Federation and Klingon ambassadors look very silly. This is the main
bulk of the book, though I forget if the point was to embarrass them
into playing nice on the spot, or to generate blackmail material.
In tFR, Captain Krenn figures out the human concept of "silly" and uses
it to his advantage, by being one unarmed polite Klingon where the
Federation expected a snarling dangerous horde. This is a small part of
the book, or perhaps more accurately a quiet part of the book, but a
significant one.
Anyway, I've read both books multiple times, but just noticed that on
the last re-read of tFR. I figured I'd share.
-xx- Damien X-)
[1] Though the space combat scenes have all the realism of, well, a very
unrealistic thing.
[2] There's a second element in common -- and distinct from most other
Star Trek novels or shows in any series. They take the Organian Peace
Treaty seriously; the lightbulbs are still on the job.