On Mar 22, 9:47 pm, Don Tiberone <***@my-Deja.com> wrote:
In 1972, Friedman helped persuade U.S. Treasury Secretary George
Shultz, former dean of Chicago’s business school, to approve the first
financial futures contracts in foreign currencies, Such derivatives
grew more complex after Chicago economists created the mathematical
formulas to price them, helping spawn a $683 trillion market that’s
proved to be a root of today’s financial system breakdown “When
Friedman’s Platonic ideas of free-market virtues are put into
practice, they have too often generated a systemic orgy of competitive
greed -- whose remedies, ironically, entail countermeasures of
nationalization,” they are now finished, SNICKER!
where are all of the stupid cranks that are indoctrinated in the
sleazy, unworkable, dangerous, crank science going to work now. they
are the laughing stock of the world, the butt of jokes from sea to
shining sea.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601109&sid=a3GVhIHGyWRM&refer=home
Friedman Would Be Roiled as Chicago Disciples Rue Repudiation
By John Lippert
Dec. 23 (Bloomberg) -- John Cochrane was steaming as word of U.S.
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson’s plan to buy $700 billion in
troubled mortgage assets rippled across the University of Chicago in
September.
Cochrane had been teaching at the bastion of free-market economics for
14 years and this struck at everything that he -- and the school --
stood for.
“We all wandered the hallway thinking, How could this possibly make
sense?” says Cochrane, 51, recalling his incredulity at Paulson’s
attempt to prop up the mortgage industry and the banks that had
precipitated the housing market’s boom and bust.
During a lunch held on a balcony with a view of Rockefeller Memorial
Chapel, Cochrane, son-in-law of Chicago efficient-market theorist
Eugene Fama, and some colleagues made their stand.
They wrote a petition attacking Paulson’s proposal, sent it to
economists nationwide and collected 230 signatures. Republican Senator
Richard Shelby of Alabama waved the document as he scorned the rescue.
When Congress rejected it on Sept. 29, Cochrane fired off
congratulatory e-mails.
The victory was short-lived. Lawmakers approved the plan four days
later, swayed by what Cochrane calls a pinata of pork-barrel
amendments.
“We should have a recession,” Cochrane said in November, speaking to
students and investors in a conference room that looks out on Lake
Michigan. “People who spend their lives pounding nails in Nevada need
something else to do.”
Unusual Role
At the University of Chicago, once ascendant free-market acolytes are
finding themselves in an unusual role: They’re battling a wave of
government intervention more sweeping than any since the Great
Depression as the U.S. struggles with the worst recession in seven
decades.
By the end of November, the government had committed $8.5 trillion, or
more than half the value of everything produced in the country in
2007, to save the financial system.
The European Union had ponied up more than $3 trillion to guarantee
bank loans and provide capital to lenders. And China had unveiled a
$586 billion stimulus plan and its biggest interest-rate cut in 11
years.
The intrusion is anathema to the so-called Chicago School of economics
and its patriarch, the late Milton Friedman.
Nobel Dominance
For half a century, Chicago’s hands-off principles have permeated
financial thinking and shaped global markets, earning the university
10 Nobel Memorial Prizes in Economic Sciences starting in 1969, more
than double the four each won by Columbia University, Harvard
University, Princeton University and the University of California,
Berkeley.
Chicago’s laissez-faire imprint underpins everything from U.S.
President Ronald Reagan’s 1981 tax cuts and the fall of communism that
decade to quantitative investment strategies.
In 1972, Friedman helped persuade U.S. Treasury Secretary George
Shultz, former dean of Chicago’s business school, to approve the first
financial futures contracts in foreign currencies.
Such derivatives grew more complex after Chicago economists created
the mathematical formulas to price them, helping spawn a $683 trillion
market that’s proved to be a root of today’s financial system
breakdown.
On Dec. 16, the U.S. Federal Reserve cut its target lending rate to as
low as zero for the first time and said it will buy mortgage- backed
securities.
Free Market
Friedman, who died in 2006 at age 94, defined the Chicago School in
1974 as he spoke to a board of trustees dinner.
“‘Chicago’ stands for a belief in the efficacy of the free market as a
means of organizing resources, for skepticism about government
intervention into economic affairs,” he said.
Friedman was explaining a movement that had taken hold in the U.S. and
was percolating in Europe and South America.
“By the mid-1970s, there was a whole generation in government and
academia who’d trained at Chicago or places influenced by it,” says
Ross Emmett, a Michigan State University professor who’s written three
books on the school.
Today, 10 percent of Chicago undergraduates study economics. Alumni of
Chicago’s graduate business school, now called the Booth School of
Business, run states and companies.
Jon Corzine, the former chief executive officer of Goldman, Sachs &
Co. who earned his MBA in 1973, is governor of New Jersey. Peter
Peterson, who graduated with an MBA in 1951, co-founded Blackstone
Group LP, the world’s largest private equity firm.
David Booth, a 1971 MBA graduate for whom the school is now named,
donated $300 million in November, the largest endowment given to the
university.
Booth School
Booth, who founded Dimensional Fund Advisors Inc., bases his funds on
Fama’s theory that a market digests information affecting prices so
well that even professional investors can’t outsmart it for long. Even
with his U.S. Micro Cap Portfolio fund down 40 percent in 2008 through
Dec. 22, Booth says quantitative investing is less vulnerable during a
slump than stock picking that relies on human judgment.
“This supports our theory in that predicting the market is even more
difficult than we expected,” he says.
Unlike Booth, 62, much of the academic world is reassessing Chicago
School hallmarks. That’s true even in the limestone buildings on the
211-acre (85-hectare) Hyde Park campus in which professors teach
Friedman’s theories.
‘Systemic Orgy’
On Oct. 14, about 250 students and professors debated an
administration-backed plan for a $200 million research center to be
named for Friedman. The protesters argued that the institute would
enshrine policies that have brought economies near collapse.
“When Friedman’s Platonic ideas of free-market virtues are put into
practice, they have too often generated a systemic orgy of competitive
greed -- whose remedies, ironically, entail countermeasures of
nationalization,” Marshall Sahlins, an emeritus professor of
anthropology, said during the debate, speaking in a room adorned with
murals of female students parading through the campus in medieval
gowns.
Sahlins, 77, noted a few weeks later socialist and capitalist
countries alike are regulating or nationalizing financial institutions
in a rebuff to Friedman.
Off campus, the global meltdown is stirring anti-Chicago economists,
who were voices in the wilderness during decades of lax government
oversight of markets.
Joseph Stiglitz, who won one of Columbia’s economics Nobels, says the
approach of Friedman and his followers helped cause today’s turmoil.
‘Bears the Blame’
“The Chicago School bears the blame for providing a seeming
intellectual foundation for the idea that markets are self- adjusting
and the best role for government is to do nothing,” says Stiglitz, 65,
who received his Nobel in 2001.
University of Texas economist James Galbraith says Friedman’s ideology
has run its course. He says hands-off policies were convenient for
American capitalists after World War II as they vied with government-
favored labor unions at home and Soviet expansion overseas.
“The inability of Friedman’s successors to say anything useful about
what’s happening in financial markets today means their influence is
finished,” he says.
Instead, Galbraith, 56, says policy-makers are rediscovering the ideas
of his father, Harvard professor John Kenneth Galbraith, and economist
John Maynard Keynes of the University of Cambridge.
Keynes, who died in 1946, argued that governments should spend to
combat the unemployment that free markets tolerate. Galbraith, who
died in 2006, rejected mathematical models and technical analyses as
divorced from reality.
Obama’s Role
Barack Obama, who will referee the laissez-faire versus free- market
debate as U.S. president, has pledged the largest spending on
infrastructure since the 1950s to save or create 3 million jobs.
Obama, 47, has deep roots on the university’s campus in Hyde Park, a
middle-class enclave 7 miles south of downtown Chicago. His Victorian
house is a five-minute walk from the school’s northern edge. He taught
constitutional law there for 12 years, stepping down when he was
elected to the U.S. Senate in 2004.
Obama tapped fellow Chicago professor Austan Goolsbee as staff
director of his President’s Economic Recovery Advisory Board, which
will propose ways to revive growth.
Goolsbee, 39, who was Obama’s chief economist during the campaign, has
taught at the business school since 1995. Goolsbee says Obama’s top
priority is to prevent the crisis from spiraling into a depression.
Yet he insists Obama won’t overregulate.
‘Chicago School’ Democrat
“If the president-elect were not a ‘University of Chicago Democrat,’
then the natural response would be to just try to turn back the clock
to what was there before,” he says.
“Because Obama comes out of a framework where the market is not the
enemy, there’s a possibility we can create new institutions to guard
against excess without going back to what was wrong in the old
regime.”
Goolsbee supports bigger capital requirements for banks and other
institutions that can borrow from the Federal Reserve, and wants
expanded monitoring of hedge fund firms and ratings companies.
Derivatives may need to be traded through clearinghouses, like those
used in Chicago wheat pits, which act as counterparties for each trade
and can suspend traders with insufficient collateral.
“Getting us out of the hole we’re in, promoting oversight and making
investments so the economy can grow doesn’t make you anti- market,”
Goolsbee says. “It’s totally pro-market.”
Already, some of the university’s top economists have abandoned hard-
line Friedmanism for the middle ground.
Douglas Diamond, a finance professor at Chicago since 1979, declined
to sign Cochrane’s petition damning Paulson’s bailout. Diamond says he
knew the Sept. 29 vote against the rescue would spur investors to pull
assets from banks. He says governments have no choice but to provide
safety nets for banks and tougher oversight.
‘Crazy Stuff’
“The vote was the beginning of people believing crazy stuff, like the
U.S. might find it politically expedient to let its financial system
go,” Diamond, 55, says.
Robert Lucas, a Chicago economist who won a Nobel in 1995 for a theory
that argued against governments trying to fine-tune consumer demand,
says deregulation may have gone too far.
Depression-era laws that separated commercial and investment banks
helped depositors decide if they wanted secure accounts or riskier
investments. Today, without these distinctions, people can’t be sure
if their investments, or those of their customers, are safe.
“I’m changing my views on bank regulation every week,” Lucas, 71,
says. “It was an area I saw as under control. Now I don’t believe
that.”
Lucas says he voted for Obama, the only Democrat besides Bill Clinton
he’d supported in 44 years. He concluded the candidate was comfortable
talking with professional economists. He describes Goolsbee, whom he
has met in faculty workshops, as a serious scholar.
‘Survival of Fittest’
Chicago students seem less concerned about the debate swirling through
their campus than with finding -- or keeping -- a job.
Milos Dedovic, an emigre from Serbia, is studying for his MBA at
night. He works for Continental AG, Europe’s second-largest auto parts
maker, managing sales of transmission control modules to General
Motors Corp. Dedovic, 38, says his MBA will help make him secure even
if he loses his job.
“If the economy is spiraling down, you get survival of the fittest,
where skills and accreditation matter even more,” he says.
The university got its start in 1892 as a haven for researchers, not
would-be managers.
William Rainey Harper, a Bible scholar who taught at Yale, attracted
oil magnate John D. Rockefeller as his benefactor. Harper broke with
then prevailing Ivy League practices by hiring Jews, finance professor
Fama says. By 1946, Chicago was luring stars such as Enrico Fermi,
father of the self-sustaining nuclear reaction.
Keynesian Orthodoxy
Friedman’s parents were Jews who emigrated from what’s now Ukraine.
When he joined the faculty in 1946, he allied with Friedrich Hayek, a
London School of Economics professor who later transferred to Chicago.
They sought to discredit Keynes, who argued that deficits in
government budgets could revive demand in recessions. They viewed
rising government power as a step toward left-wing totalitarianism and
wanted to stop it, says Philip Mirowski, a University of Notre Dame
economist.
Friedman challenged Keynesian orthodoxy with work that culminated in a
Nobel Prize in 1976. He argued that consumers decide how much to save
based on earnings prospects throughout their lifetimes, not on short-
term government efforts to manipulate demand. Friedman demonstrated
that inflation and unemployment may rise in tandem and that
governments cause inflation by printing too much money.
‘Change My Mind’
Lucas, the 1995 Nobel laureate, recalls Friedman convincing him in a
90-minute undergraduate class in 1960 that labor was subject to the
same economic laws as other commodities. Friedman argued that minimum
wage laws, which Lucas saw as humanitarian, harm workers by reducing
demand for their services.
“I never thought I could change my mind like that,” Lucas says.
Deirdre McCloskey, now an economist at the University of Illinois,
Chicago, remembers laughing with fellow Harvard undergraduates in 1963
at Friedman’s claim that free markets allocate resources better than
governments. She says Harvard-trained bureaucrats enjoyed prestige
following World War II. She switched her support to Friedman after the
Vietnam War destroyed her faith that such bureaucrats knew what they
were doing.
Friedman, who stood 5 feet 3 inches (160 centimeters), was a fierce
debater, McCloskey recalls.
“He always asks, persistently, ‘How do you know?’” McCloskey, now 66,
wrote in the Eastern Economic Review in 2003. “It’s a terrifying
question, because most of the time we can’t say.”
‘Shock Therapy’
Friedman was chief economic adviser to Republican presidential
candidate Barry Goldwater in 1964. He began attracting nonacademic
audiences with a Newsweek magazine column that ran from 1966 to ’84.
When Reagan was governor of California, Friedman campaigned with him
in 1973 for limits to property taxes that had fueled government growth
in the state.
In 1975, Friedman traveled to Chile and met dictator Augusto Pinochet,
who’d seized power two years earlier in a coup in which thousands
died, including Socialist President Salvador Allende. Pinochet
practiced “shock therapy,” including monetary controls, to tame
inflation.
Friedman’s friend Alan Walters, later an adviser to British Prime
Minister Margaret Thatcher, went to Chile to monitor what he viewed as
laboratory-like conditions for shock therapy, says Andy Beckett in
“Pinochet in Piccadilly” (Faber & Faber, 2002).
India and China
Walters, 82, taught at the London School of Economics and at Johns
Hopkins University in Baltimore, later serving as vice chairman of AIG
Trading Group Inc. He was fascinated by “the Chicago boys” who trained
in Hyde Park and became advisers to post-Soviet governments in Eastern
Europe after serving in Chile.
Students reacted differently. After the coup, a generation of Latin
Americans refused to study at Chicago, says James Heckman, 64, an
economist at the university who won a Nobel in 2000.
McCloskey, who taught in the Chicago economics department for 12 years
starting in 1968, says several professors played bigger roles than
Friedman in Chile. His opposition to training economists for Shah
Mohammed Reza Pahlavi of Iran shows he didn’t coddle dictators, she
says. McCloskey still trusts Friedman’s teachings.
“The big event of the last 20 years is the success of free markets in
India and China,” says McCloskey via telephone from South Africa,
where she’s a visiting professor at the University of the Free State
in Bloemfontein.
“This is more important than any financial crisis and makes it really
hard to argue for a return to central planning.”
In 1977, Friedman reached the then mandatory retirement age of 65 and
left for the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.
Black-Scholes
While wrapping up his Hyde Park career, he reviewed the early research
of professors Fischer Black and Myron Scholes, who gave Chicago
theories a bigger and more direct role in financial markets.
The pair provided a foundation for trading call options on stocks by
creating a formula to link the value of the options to share price and
volatility, time remaining on the option and interest rates.
The Black-Scholes model helped spark the global derivatives market.
At the time, Fama was positing that securities prices reflect the
collective wisdom of all participants. This “efficient market” theory
helped make him the No. 1 scholarly business writer, with 250,828
downloads of academic papers as of Dec. 22, according to Social
Science Research Network.
Fama’s theory helped pave the way for the recent economic crisis by
sanctioning limited government, Notre Dame’s Mirowski says.
“Fama taught that no human being knows enough to understand how
resources should be allocated,” he says. “All you can do is let the
market have greater and greater ability to repackage information and
risk. The result is, people bought mortgage-backed securities with no
idea whether borrowers could repay.”
AIG’s Long Position
Fama, 69, who favors casual shirts and chinos on campus, joined the
Chicago faculty in 1963. When he opened his financial theory class on
Sept. 29, the day Congress voted down Paulson’s bailout, he placed
efficient-market equations from his 1976 textbook on an overhead
projector.
Fama says he never denied the possibility of unexpected events even
though he’d spent a lifetime showing that markets effectively digest
information. He was stunned that American International Group Inc.,
once the world’s largest insurer, sold $441 billion in unhedged and
undercapitalized insurance on securitized debt, much of it tied to
mortgage values.
“No one expected a player like AIG to take a long position and not
hedge themselves,” Fama says. He says the government may have been
able to stabilize the U.S. financial system at a lower cost by letting
AIG collapse.
Bailout Mania
Bailing out Detroit automakers will simply postpone their demise as
they reel from expenses promised for employee retirement plans, he
says.
Cochrane, who circulated the anti-rescue petition, says a rash of
bailouts will expand government and kill entrepreneurship.
“People don’t notice businesses that didn’t start,” he says. Cochrane
says he was encouraged by the Fed’s Dec. 16 rate cut and its plan to
buy mortgage-backed securities, saying these moves will help unfreeze
capital markets.
“This is exactly the right thing for a central bank to be doing in the
midst of a credit crunch,” he says.
Fama and Cochrane have more in common than their outlooks. Cochrane is
married to Fama’s daughter Elizabeth, a finance Ph.D. who writes
fiction for young adults. Their families have dinner together twice a
week; on campus, their offices adjoin.
Cochrane’s Vindication
Cochrane’s has a photo of himself in a glider in which he competes. He
says he felt vindicated in November when Paulson abandoned the idea of
buying mortgage assets. He advocates patience as markets rebuild
themselves.
In the future, people who originate securities will retain a higher
percentage of the debt, understand risks better and earn smaller
profits, he says.
For now, he says, when a U.S. bank fails, a hedge fund in Denmark may
bear the brunt, which is an improvement from the Depression era, when
neighborhoods surrounding a bank were devastated.
“That’s risk being spread all around the world,” he says.
Cochrane says he now represents a minority viewpoint among Chicago’s
business faculty. He says Diamond, who declined to sign the petition,
holds a majority view, which posits financial institutions must be
rescued and regulated.
Bank Failures
Diamond began studying bank failures when he was a doctoral student at
Yale in the 1970s. The 1963 book that Friedman wrote with Anna
Schwartz, “A Monetary History of the United States, 1867- 1960,”
provided the foundation. A copy, held together by Scotch tape, sits on
Diamond’s desk, even though he concluded at Yale that a main premise
was wrong.
Diamond rejects Friedman’s view that banks failed in the 1930s because
the U.S. money supply contracted as panicky Americans started hoarding
cash and the Fed reacted too slowly. Diamond sees the money supply as
less significant than Friedman did.
Banks failed, he says, because their assets weren’t readily converted
into the cash that depositors were demanding.
During the 1980s, Diamond’s research was similar to that of Fed
Chairman Ben S. Bernanke, 55, whom he calls a good friend. The two
postulated that because bankers accumulate experience in assessing
risk, they play a key role in the economy.
In the past decade, bankers failed to properly grasp risk because of a
“witch’s brew” of mistakes, Diamond says.
Real-Life Experiment
Former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan’s 1 percent interest rate in 2003
-- a 45-year low -- flooded Wall Street with so much cash that banks
could increase profits with short-term borrowing to service long-term
liabilities, Diamond says. The mismatch grew more dangerous as
Greenspan resisted regulation of off-balance-sheet structured
investment vehicles, which banks used to circumvent capital
requirements.
Reagan’s $4.5 billion rescue of Continental Illinois National Bank &
Trust Co. in 1984 convinced bankers that bailouts would come if things
turned bad, Diamond says.
By 2007, a quarter of assets held by big U.S. investment banks came
from short-term borrowing, up from 12 percent three years earlier.
Goolsbee describes the plan Obama is formulating -- tax relief for
workers, investment in technology and infrastructure and more
oversight of financial markets -- as pragmatic and data-driven. He
says Friedman would approve of Obama’s determination to keep policy
making rooted in the economic methodologies developed at Chicago.
The University of Texas’s Galbraith compares Obama to pragmatic
philosopher John Dewey, whose ideas sparked educational reform in the
20th century. While on the Chicago faculty in 1896, Dewey started the
school that the Obama and Goolsbee children attend.
With his inauguration on Jan. 20, Obama faces a real-life experiment
in organizing financial markets amid turmoil few presidents have
navigated.
His success will be measured partly by how he uses the University of
Chicago as an intellectual anchor -- and whether he can meld its free-
market heritage with today’s nonstop intervention to bring order to
uncharted times.
To contact the reporter on this story: John Lippert in Chicago at
***@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: December 23, 2008 00:01 EST