On 2/12/11 9:07 PM, jrsnfld wrote:
(snip)
Post by jrsnfldI purposely left the Emersons off my lists, so I should comment: I
heard them give an enthralling survey of the Beethoven quartets over
the years, coupled I think with Shostakovich on the same programs.
They are an incredible group and they sound like they know Beethoven
inside out, including on their CDs. Those were great concerts, but
maybe now I'm glad I don't live with that Beethoven at home.
So what's my objection? I guess I equate them a bit with recordings
like Karajan's Strauss, Solti's Wagner, and Toscanini's Beethoven (you
could insert a lot else, but I'm generalizing very broadly here about
each of these). These are fantastic documents all, and I do like them
plenty--maybe more than most people--but I also sense my reaction is
often more like, "Holy Cow, you can make an orchestra do *that*!?"
than anything else.
So the Emersons Beethoven--and I just listened to their 59:1 a bit
today for fun--is a lot like that: "Holy Cow! You can make a string
quartet do *that*!?" Fascinating to the ears, total control, vigorous
sensual excitement. It's a great aesthetic experience, but it's not,
in my soul of souls, about Beethoven.
That's exactly my objection to the Emersons in general. The playing is
absolutely unimpeachable, but in the end it all too frequently isn't
*about* anything. That said, I believe they *can* do it. One of the
greatest performances of anything I ever heard was their Op. 59/3 at
Chamber Music NW some years ago. It closed the first half of the
concert, and at its conclusion the audience positively erupted, and was
right to do so. That performance had it all. After intermission came Op.
131. Perfectly played, but little soul. Too bad.
Bob Harper
Post by jrsnfldThere's wit, but not really charm, not really a feeling of an
experience that takes you from one state of being to another. Instead,
bring a double espresso and be amazed, over and over, but end up just
as wired as you were before you started listening.
I can see why this is a favorite for some people. Nothing wrong with
that.
--Jeff