Michael Pendragon
2019-10-12 05:25:25 UTC
First the hits:
1946
1) THAT'S MY DESIRE
This was Frankie Laine's first hit (and first gold record), in December of 1946 -- almost 17 years after he left home to pursue a singing career. Laine had been singing at Billy Berg's nightclub in Hollywood, but was basically a "house" singer who entertained between the featured acts (partially to help clear the house for a new set of patrons). One night, on the spur of the moment, he called for the audience's attention and announced that he was going to sing a "new" song for them (he meant "new to his usual playlist," as the song had been around since 1931. The audience, however, mistook it for a new song... and listened.
The song peaked at #4 on the charts and turned Laine into an "overnight" sensation. Here's the original recording, back by Mannie Klein's All Stars:
I've got 13 versions of this song by Laine: 6 records, 1 unreleased alternate take, and 6 live performances.
My favorite version is from his 1957 "Rockin'" album with Paul Weston's orchestra.
1947
2) (WHAT DID I DO TO BE SO) BLACK & BLUE
Because Laine sang in "black" style, listeners who weren't familiar with his show at Billy Berg's assumed that he was black. Fats Waller's "Black & Blue" helped to further that impression. Back by Carl Fischer's Swingtet, it peaked at #27.
I've got four versions of this by Laine (3 recordings, 1 unreleased alternate take), and am partial to both the hit version and the "Rockin'" album cut:
3) MAM'SELLE
"Mam'selle" was the theme song from the 1947 movie hit, "The Razor's Edge," and had been co-written by the film's director, Edmund Goulding. Art Lund had a #1 hit with it, and there were competing hit versions by Frank Sinatra, Dick Haymes, Dennis Day, and The Pied Pipers. Frankie Laine's version didn't break the top ten, peaking at #14, but it was the first version I'd heard and the one I consider to be definitive. I have four versions of this by Laine (2 records and 2 unreleased alternate takes). Here's the hit version, backed by Harry Geller's ork:
I'm equally fond of the version he cut with Michel Legrand for their 1958 "Foreign Affair" album, which includes the introduction:
4) ON THE SUNNY SIDE OF THE STREET
Written in 1930, this song had long been a jazz standard when Laine recorded it (it had also been a smash hit for Tommy Dorsey & The Sentimentalists two years earlier). I can't find any chart info on Laine's recording (the charts often only listed the Top 10 at that time), but it became his second gold record and is often included on his greatest hits albums. I've got 11 versions of this one by Laine (4 records, 4 movie soundtracks, 3 live perfs). Here's the hit version with Carl Fischer's Swingtet:
And the equally great version from the classic "Rockin'" album?
5) TWO LOVES HAVE I
This is a (relatively) laid back romantic number that peaked at #21 and brought Laine his third gold record. I've got two recordings of it by Laine. This is the hit one, backed by Harry Geller's ork.
And this is the version I (slightly) prefer, backed by Carl Fischer's Swingtet:
Carl Fischer, btw, was Laine's pianist-musical director-song writing partner until his death in 1954. Their recording is from what was known as a "radio transcription" - radios generally didn't broadcast the actual records that were available to the public, but specially made electronic transcriptions. By the time Laine hit in the post WWII era, transcriptions were well on the way out. Laine's transcriptions had been thought lost, but 49 of them were discovered in a box in 1980 and reissued.
1948
6) SHINE
"Shine" dates back to 1910 and it purportedly celebrates a real-life personage known today only by his nickname, "Shine." Shine is said to have been a close friend of vaudevillian George Walker, and was with him during the New York City race riots of 1900. As in "Black & Blue," the lyrics imply that Laine is a black singer, although by this point, people knew what he looked like. Laine's version peaked at #9 and brought him his fourth gold record.
Oddly, the song has acquired a reputation in recent days for being politically incorrect. "Shine," it seems, was a derogatory term for persons of color at the time. However, assuming this to be the case, the song becomes a defiant stance against the racial prejudices of its day. The lyrics turn a racial slur inside out, by taking a negative term, "Shine," and recasting it in a positive light. The singer claims he is called "Shine," not for being a black man, but for having a bright, friendly, and extremely stylish personality. It throws the slur back in the faces of those who would use it as an insult, by turning it into something to be proud of.
I've got four recordings of this by Laine. This is his hit version, backed by Harry Geller's ork:
7) MONDAY AGAIN
This song peaked at #24 and is another relatively laid back, blues-tinted ballad. Here he is, backed by Carl Fischer's ork:
This is one of several records that were cut by both Laine and Nat "King" Cole. Cole was one of Laine's biggest musical influences, and the similarity of their styles in the late 1940s can be readily heard when comparing their versions. Here's Nat Cole & The King Cole Trio:
8) BABY, THAT AIN'T RIGHT (a.k.a. THAT AIN'T RIGHT)
This song had been Nat Cole's first success in 1942, topping the R&B charts. Laine's remake peaked on the Popular charts at #20. I've got five versions of this one by Laine (4 recordings and 1 live broadcast). Here's his hit version backed by Carl Fisher's ork:
9) YOU'RE ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS
Frankie Laine never cut a Christmas album, but he did cut a few Christmas songs over the years. This one hit at #11. I've got 2 versions of this by Laine, both equally good. This is the hit version, backed by Carl Fisher:
10) AH, BUT IT HAPPENS
I've got two versions of this by Laine -- one's supposedly an unreleased alternate take, although I can't tell them apart. This one made it to #21, and Laine is once again backed by Carl Fisher's ork.
***
These are Frankie Laine's early hits from his first three years under contract to Mercury Records. Mercury was the first major label Laine recorded for -- he'd previously cut several sides for two"race" labels, Bel-Tone and Atlas. Laine was considered more of a jazz singer than a pop vocalist in those days. His pop phase would begin when Mitch Miller took over as A&R man at Mercury in 1949.
In the next post, I'll list some of my favorite non-hit FL records from this period, then continue alternating between his hits and non-hits.
1946
1) THAT'S MY DESIRE
This was Frankie Laine's first hit (and first gold record), in December of 1946 -- almost 17 years after he left home to pursue a singing career. Laine had been singing at Billy Berg's nightclub in Hollywood, but was basically a "house" singer who entertained between the featured acts (partially to help clear the house for a new set of patrons). One night, on the spur of the moment, he called for the audience's attention and announced that he was going to sing a "new" song for them (he meant "new to his usual playlist," as the song had been around since 1931. The audience, however, mistook it for a new song... and listened.
The song peaked at #4 on the charts and turned Laine into an "overnight" sensation. Here's the original recording, back by Mannie Klein's All Stars:
I've got 13 versions of this song by Laine: 6 records, 1 unreleased alternate take, and 6 live performances.
My favorite version is from his 1957 "Rockin'" album with Paul Weston's orchestra.
1947
2) (WHAT DID I DO TO BE SO) BLACK & BLUE
Because Laine sang in "black" style, listeners who weren't familiar with his show at Billy Berg's assumed that he was black. Fats Waller's "Black & Blue" helped to further that impression. Back by Carl Fischer's Swingtet, it peaked at #27.
I've got four versions of this by Laine (3 recordings, 1 unreleased alternate take), and am partial to both the hit version and the "Rockin'" album cut:
3) MAM'SELLE
"Mam'selle" was the theme song from the 1947 movie hit, "The Razor's Edge," and had been co-written by the film's director, Edmund Goulding. Art Lund had a #1 hit with it, and there were competing hit versions by Frank Sinatra, Dick Haymes, Dennis Day, and The Pied Pipers. Frankie Laine's version didn't break the top ten, peaking at #14, but it was the first version I'd heard and the one I consider to be definitive. I have four versions of this by Laine (2 records and 2 unreleased alternate takes). Here's the hit version, backed by Harry Geller's ork:
I'm equally fond of the version he cut with Michel Legrand for their 1958 "Foreign Affair" album, which includes the introduction:
4) ON THE SUNNY SIDE OF THE STREET
Written in 1930, this song had long been a jazz standard when Laine recorded it (it had also been a smash hit for Tommy Dorsey & The Sentimentalists two years earlier). I can't find any chart info on Laine's recording (the charts often only listed the Top 10 at that time), but it became his second gold record and is often included on his greatest hits albums. I've got 11 versions of this one by Laine (4 records, 4 movie soundtracks, 3 live perfs). Here's the hit version with Carl Fischer's Swingtet:
And the equally great version from the classic "Rockin'" album?
5) TWO LOVES HAVE I
This is a (relatively) laid back romantic number that peaked at #21 and brought Laine his third gold record. I've got two recordings of it by Laine. This is the hit one, backed by Harry Geller's ork.
And this is the version I (slightly) prefer, backed by Carl Fischer's Swingtet:
Carl Fischer, btw, was Laine's pianist-musical director-song writing partner until his death in 1954. Their recording is from what was known as a "radio transcription" - radios generally didn't broadcast the actual records that were available to the public, but specially made electronic transcriptions. By the time Laine hit in the post WWII era, transcriptions were well on the way out. Laine's transcriptions had been thought lost, but 49 of them were discovered in a box in 1980 and reissued.
1948
6) SHINE
"Shine" dates back to 1910 and it purportedly celebrates a real-life personage known today only by his nickname, "Shine." Shine is said to have been a close friend of vaudevillian George Walker, and was with him during the New York City race riots of 1900. As in "Black & Blue," the lyrics imply that Laine is a black singer, although by this point, people knew what he looked like. Laine's version peaked at #9 and brought him his fourth gold record.
Oddly, the song has acquired a reputation in recent days for being politically incorrect. "Shine," it seems, was a derogatory term for persons of color at the time. However, assuming this to be the case, the song becomes a defiant stance against the racial prejudices of its day. The lyrics turn a racial slur inside out, by taking a negative term, "Shine," and recasting it in a positive light. The singer claims he is called "Shine," not for being a black man, but for having a bright, friendly, and extremely stylish personality. It throws the slur back in the faces of those who would use it as an insult, by turning it into something to be proud of.
I've got four recordings of this by Laine. This is his hit version, backed by Harry Geller's ork:
7) MONDAY AGAIN
This song peaked at #24 and is another relatively laid back, blues-tinted ballad. Here he is, backed by Carl Fischer's ork:
This is one of several records that were cut by both Laine and Nat "King" Cole. Cole was one of Laine's biggest musical influences, and the similarity of their styles in the late 1940s can be readily heard when comparing their versions. Here's Nat Cole & The King Cole Trio:
8) BABY, THAT AIN'T RIGHT (a.k.a. THAT AIN'T RIGHT)
This song had been Nat Cole's first success in 1942, topping the R&B charts. Laine's remake peaked on the Popular charts at #20. I've got five versions of this one by Laine (4 recordings and 1 live broadcast). Here's his hit version backed by Carl Fisher's ork:
9) YOU'RE ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS
Frankie Laine never cut a Christmas album, but he did cut a few Christmas songs over the years. This one hit at #11. I've got 2 versions of this by Laine, both equally good. This is the hit version, backed by Carl Fisher:
10) AH, BUT IT HAPPENS
I've got two versions of this by Laine -- one's supposedly an unreleased alternate take, although I can't tell them apart. This one made it to #21, and Laine is once again backed by Carl Fisher's ork.
***
These are Frankie Laine's early hits from his first three years under contract to Mercury Records. Mercury was the first major label Laine recorded for -- he'd previously cut several sides for two"race" labels, Bel-Tone and Atlas. Laine was considered more of a jazz singer than a pop vocalist in those days. His pop phase would begin when Mitch Miller took over as A&R man at Mercury in 1949.
In the next post, I'll list some of my favorite non-hit FL records from this period, then continue alternating between his hits and non-hits.