Cloud Writer
2004-10-14 16:09:47 UTC
Some converted wsp files online: http://tinyurl.com/6jaxv
fyi [CAP] [WASPC] [WSP] TPD David Fischer
Citizens Advisory Panel (CAP) for the Washington Association of
Sheriffs and Police Chiefs ("WASPC") Investigation Report and
Recommendations
Page 10
...The Citizens Advisory Panel thoroughly reviewed the evidence
presented and sought to uncover the good while dealing with the bad.
For example, Sergeant David Fischer showed both professionalism and
courage in 1996 by going beyond standard procedures to ensure Crystal
Brame's safety following a `911' call from her...
http://www.ci.tacoma.wa.us/cronews/WASPC_Committee_ReportOct4.pdf
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/police_dv/message/1615
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Crystal_Judson/message/7709
WASPC BOOK2
Page 328
4 Pages
TPD FISCHER INTERVIEW_BK2P328_4PP
WASHINGTON STATE PATROL
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION DIVISION
Investigative Report
FILE TITLE David
Brame
DETECTIVE Sergeant Michael B. Haw
CASE NUMBER 03-004969
SUBJECT David Fischer Interview.
SYNOPSIS:
On October 3, 2003, Washington State Patrol (WSP) Detective Sergeant
Michael B. Haw and WSP Lieutenant Grant Hulteen interviewed Tacoma
Police Department (TPD) Officer David Fischer. Fischer provided
information regarding a domestic violence incident involving David
and Crystal Brame, and Fischer's subsequent phone conversation with
Crystal the same evening. The interview was not tape-recorded. <?>
DETAILS:
1996 Domestic Violence Incident
On October 3, 2003, Washington State Patrol (WSP) Detective Sergeant
Michael B. Haw and WSP Lieutenant Grant Hulteen interviewed Tacoma
Police Department (TPD) Officer David Fischer. Fischer was
interviewed subsequent to a letter Fischer sent to WSP Criminal
Investigation Division Commander Captain Brian Ursino (dated May 21,
2003) in which Fischer described an incident involving David and
Crystal Brame which occurred in 1996.1
Fischer said he has been Police Patrol Officer (PPO) with TPD for
fifteen years, and was assigned as an acting sergeant approximately
eighty-percent of the period between April 1994 and January 1997.
Fischer stated that sometime in 1996, but prior to December of that
year, (Fischer could not recall the specific date) he was assigned as
a temporary or acting sergeant with TPD, working the
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 2 of 4
graveyard shift.2 Fischer said he was contacted by the
communications center <?> and advised Crystal Brame had made a 911
call regarding a domestic dispute involving herself and her husband,
David Brame. Fischer said he called the Brame residence and contacted
Crystal, who was, ".. .almost hysterical". According to Fischer.
Crystal was crying, and advised Fischer that she just had a big
argument with David Brame, although Fischer could not recall <?> what
the argument was about, he thought it was about something minor. <?>
Fisher said he asked Crystal if David had physically assaulted her,
and she stated he had not. Fischer also asked Crystal if David had
threatened her and she denied this. Fischer stated Crystal told him
David had left the house with his weapons, and Fisher asked Crystal
if Brame had made threats to harm himself, and Crystal stated he had
not, and that she did not know what he [Brame] was going to do.
According to Fischer, Crystal said David Brame might have gone to his
parent's house.Fischer stated he believed at the time that Brame had
perhaps taken his weapons to separate them from Crystal, or maybe
Brame planned to spend the night elsewhere, in which case Brame would
need the weapons for work the next day. Fischer said Crystal seemed
very upset that Brame had taken the weapons.
Fischer said he advised Crystal he was going to have a Gig Harbor <?>
Police officer contact her residence to check on her and told her to
be sure to open the door so the officer could be sure she was not
injured. Although Fischer believed a Gig Harbor Police officer had
already been to the residence, he was not positive they had made
contact with Crystal. Fischer stated that although Crystal was
reluctant to talk to a responding Gig Harbor officer, he was "pretty
sure" Crystal agreed to talk to him/her if an officer responded.
Fischer stated Crystal told him several times not to tell anyone
about her calling 911 because she did not want to get David Brame in
any trouble at work.
Fischer said he gave Crystal his cell phone number, and told her to
call him if David Brame returned to the residence. Fischer stated he
probably kept detailed notes in his notebook of his conversations
with Crystal and Woodard; he was unable to locate the notebook.<?>
Fischer said that after he terminated the call to Crystal, he
immediately called the night shift duty lieutenant, Catherine Woodard
and advised her of the previously described scenario. Fischer said
Woodard responded with either, "I'll handle it" or, "I'll take care
of it." Fischer stated he then asked Woodard if she wanted him to
write a report regarding the incident and/or drive to Brame's
parent's house and check on Brame. According to Fischer, Woodard
responded negatively to both options.
Fischer said he did not tell anyone about the incident,<?> and never
heard anything about how the issue between David and Crystal Brame
was resolved. Because Fischer never heard anything else about the
issue, he assumed there had been no physical altercation between the
Brame's.
_____________________
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 3 of 4
Captain William Meeks alleged Hat Theft
When asked about his knowledge of the allegation against Captain
William Meeks regarding the theft of baseball hats during a warrant
service, Fischer stated that it was common knowledge in TPD that
Meeks collected baseball hats. After Meeks was accused of the theft,
the common perception within the department was that Brame could not
possibly promote Meeks beyond the rank of captain, and that Meeks'
career was now at a "Dead end".
Fischer stated everyone knew Brame and Meeks were close friends, and
that he [Fischer] now believed Brame knew he was going to kill
himself because he promoted Meeks to assistant chief a week before he
killed himself.3
Promotional Issues
During the interview, Fischer stated he was concerned that David
Brame had found his cell phone number which Crystal had written down,
or otherwise learned about his involvement in Brame's 1996 domestic
violence incident and would hold a grudge against him. Although
Fischer stated he was unaware of the depth of Woodard and Brame's
relationship in 1996, but when he learned of the incident involving
Brame and Woodard contacting the Lane and Patty Judsen residence in
Canterwood, he believed Brame and Woodard could have conspired to
prevent him from being promoted to sergeant.
Fischer said that in December of 1996, when Fischer was first on the
sergeant's list, Woodard asked him, "How would you feel if you were
passed up?" Fischer stated he responded, "I'd probably file a
grievance because I have much more experience as an acting sergeant,
received excellent evaluations while serving in that position, and
was next on the list." According to Fischer, Woodard reacted in a
surprised manner.
Fischer stated that in 1997, after he was passed up for promotion to
sergeant, he contacted the Local 6 leadership to discuss the
possibility of filing a grievance. The Local 6 president and vice
president were Robert Blystone and David Brame, respectively.
According to Fischer, Brame and Blystone advised him his grievance
would be difficult to prove, and the union executive board voted not
to provide representation to Fischer. Fischer stated he filed an
appeal with the Civil Service Board and represented himself, and the
Board eventually decided they had no jurisdiction in Fischer's case;
Fischer stated he sent letters to City Manager Ray Corpuz and the
City Council members, to no avail.
Fischer said that when Brame was a lieutenant, everyone in TPD knew
he was being groomed for
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 4 of 4
the chiefs position. According to Fischer, "Brame knew that I knew"
[Referring to Brame's 1996 domestic incident with Crystal], but Brame
never said anything to Fischer about the incident. Fischer said that
Brame once approached him and stated, "We're getting a new board
member," Fischer asked for clarification and Brame replied, "There's
nothing better that an employee scorned." [Referring to Fischer's
grievance]
1 See Addendum AK, Fischer's letter to Ursino.
2 This incident could be the same as the one described in Detective
Norm Conaway's and David Brame's notes documenting the alleged
domestic violence which occurred on September 28, 1996.
3 Brame promoted Meeks on Monday, April 21, 2003, and on Friday,
April 26, 2003, Brame killed Crystal and himself.
4. In December 1996, Fischer held the top position on the sergeant's
list which was due to expire in January of 1997. Sergeant Catherine
McCalpine was promoted instead of Fischer, even though she was behind
Fischer on the list and had much less experience as an acting
sergeant.___________________________________________________
RECEIVED MAY 28 2003 WSP - CID FIQ
05-21-03
David Fischer
Police Patrol Officer
Tacoma Police Dept.
930 Tacoma Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98402
(253) 573-****
Captain Brian Ursino
Washington State Patrol
PO 'Box 42600
Olympia, WA 98504
RE: Criminal Investigation / David Brame
Dear Captain Ursino,
I am writing this statement in regards to some information that I
have regarding the investigation of David Brame. No one has ever
contacted me regarding this incident so I just wanted to be sure that
you have all the information that I have knowledge of for your
investigation into the Brame case.
I have tried to determine when this incident occurred, but I am
unable to find any information or date of occurrence for this
incident. I believe it occurred some time in 1996 while I was working
for the Tacoma Police Department as a Temporary and/or Acting
Sergeant on the graveyard shift.
I received a call from LESA dispatch that there was a (911) call of a
domestic dispute from Crystal Brame at their Gig Harbor home. I
believe the Gig Harbor Police responded to the Brame's residence, but
they were unable to contact anyone? I got the Brame residence's phone
number from dispatch and called the residence.
Crystal Brame answered the phone and she sounded like she was upset
and crying. I told her who I was, and that I was calling regarding
the (911) call she had made. Crystal said she and David had gotten
into an argument, but I don't recall what, or if she said what the
argument was about. I asked her if she was okay, and if there was a
physical altercation between her and David. She said she was okay,
and that they just had an argument. She sounded very upset so I again
asked her if any kind of physical violence or assault had occurred.
Crystal again said that they had only argued and nothing else
occurred.
I asked her where David was, and she said he had left. She said she
was scared because he took his guns with him when he left. Crystal
said David did not make any kind of threats to her or himself, but
she was worried that he had taken his guns with him. I asked her if
she knew where David had gone. Crystal said she wasn't sure, but she
thought he might have went to his parent's house for the night.
Crystal said two or three times during the conversation, that she was
sorry and she didn't want to get David in any trouble at work. She
also asked me not to tell anyone that she had called because she
didn't want to get David into any trouble. I asked her why she
thought she would get him in trouble if all they did was have an
argument. She said she didn't know, but she knew David would be mad
at her if he knew she had called.
I told Crystal that I was going to have a Gig Harbor Police Officer
come to her house just to check on her and make sure she was okay. I
told her that an officer needed to contact her in person to make sure
she was okay, and that she needed to tell him what had happened.
Crystal agreed to cooperate and talk with the officer when he got to
her residence. I gave Crystal my name and department cellular phone
number, and I told her to call me if she needed anything else, or to
call (911) if it was an emergency.
I then called dispatch by phone and told them to send a Gig Harbor
Police officer to the Brame residence to contact Crystal and verify
that she was okay, and that there were no signs of injuries or a
physical domestic violence incident.
Immediately after hanging up with dispatch, I called the on-duty
night shift lieutenant who was Lt. Catherine (Crews) Woodard. I told
her exactly what had happened and what Crystal Brame had told me. I
also told Woodard that I had told dispatch to send a Gig Harbor
Police officer over to check on Crystal to make sure she was okay,
and to check for any sign of a physical domestic violence incident. I
told Woodard that David had left his residence and had taken his guns
with him. I told Woodard that Crystal thought David might be going to
stay the night at his parent's residence.
After telling Woodard everything that Crystal had told me, Woodard
thanked me for telling her about the incident. I told her everything
that I had done, and asked her if there was anything else she wanted
me to do (write a report, or check on David or Crystal)? Woodard
said, no and that she would handle it.
I never heard anything about the incident after talking to Woodard
that night, not from her or anyone else. I assumed that Woodard had
followed up on the incident and determined that it was just a verbal
dispute between Crystal and David, as Crystal had told me.
Prior to this incident, I was not aware of any domestic problems
between David and Crystal Brame. I was also not aware that the
Brame's were having domestic or marital problems at any time after
this incident up until the day after David shot and killed his wife
and himself.
I was also not aware that Catherine Woodard was a good friend of
David Brame's until after the Brame's deaths.
Now that I know that Catherine Woodard and David Brame were such
close friends (as Woodard herself has stated), and now that I know
that the Brame's had been having marital and domestic violence
problems, I believe I may have been "black balled" by Woodard and
David Brame as a result of my knowledge and handling of the Brame
domestic dispute back in 1996. I also do not know if Woodard ever
reported the incident between the Brames that I informed her about,
or if she had covered for David Brame by not reporting it to anyone
or following up on the incident with the Gig Harbor Police Department.
As I stated, I was working as a Temporary Sergeant in 1996 at the
time of this incident. Near the end of 1996 there was a permanent
Sergeant position opening, and I was number (1) on the Sergeant's
list at that time. I had been working as an Acting and Temporary
Sergeant for about (2) and a half years. All of my Sergeant's
probationary reports during that time stated that I was doing an
excellent job as a Sergeant. I also had far more experience as a
Sergeant than the other officers ranked behind me on the Sergeant's
list. Yet despite being ranked number (1) on the list, and all of the
experience as a Sergeant I had, and all of the excellent ratings I
received on my Sergeant probationary reports, I was passed over for
the permanent Sergeant's position. Instead, they promoted another
officer ranked number (2) on the Sergeant's list, who had far less
experience as a Sergeant than I had. The Sergeant's list expired a
few weeks later and I never made permanent Sergeant.
At the time that I was passed over for the promotion I assumed that I
was passed over because they wanted to promote a female to the
position, and I subsequently filed a grievance and appeal on the
basis of discrimination. However, after learning what I now know
about the Brame's domestic problems, and Catherine Woodard's
involvement and close friendship with David Brame, I believe that I
was intentionally passed over for promotion because I was "black
balled" by the administration, specifically by Brame and Woodard.
I recall an incident just prior to my rule of three interview for the
Sergeant's position, in which Catherine Woodard approached me and
asked me what I would do if I didn't get the promotion. I asked her
how could I not get the promotion since I was ranked number (1) on
the Sergeant's list, had extensive experience as a Sergeant, and my
high ratings on my Sergeant's probationary reports? Woodard said, you
just never know, anything can happen. She then again asked me what I
would do if it did happen, and I didn't get promoted. I told her I
probably would file a grievance or appeal. She asked me what would I
have to file a grievance about. I again explained to her, based on my
ranking on the Sergeant's list, experience compared to the other
candidates, and my excellent ratings on my Sergeant's probationary
reports, that I was the best qualified candidate for the position.
I thought it was odd that Woodard would ask me these questions at the
time. Now, in light of everything that has happened regarding the
Brame incident, and Woodard's involvement and close friendship with
David Brame, I believe that David Brame and Catherine Woodard used
their positions in the administration to influence the decision of
the promotion in which I was passed over for. I believe they abused
their positions of authority and had me passed over for promotion to
Sergeant because of that incident in which I had talked to Crystal
Brame about the domestic dispute between her and David.
Again, I can not recall the exact date of this incident, but the Gig
Harbor Police Department may have a record of the date of the
incident, and possibly more information on what Crystal Brame may
have told the officer that contacted her that night.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions or if
you need any further information from me.
Also, please forward this information to any other agency that is
involved with the investigation of this incident such as the
Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs, Office of the
Attorney General, FBI, and any other agency involved.
Thank you. Sincerely,
David Fischer
Tacoma Police Department, PPO
It's not over til' the truth is fully known.
fyi [CAP] [WASPC] [WSP] TPD David Fischer
Citizens Advisory Panel (CAP) for the Washington Association of
Sheriffs and Police Chiefs ("WASPC") Investigation Report and
Recommendations
Page 10
...The Citizens Advisory Panel thoroughly reviewed the evidence
presented and sought to uncover the good while dealing with the bad.
For example, Sergeant David Fischer showed both professionalism and
courage in 1996 by going beyond standard procedures to ensure Crystal
Brame's safety following a `911' call from her...
http://www.ci.tacoma.wa.us/cronews/WASPC_Committee_ReportOct4.pdf
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/police_dv/message/1615
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Crystal_Judson/message/7709
WASPC BOOK2
Page 328
4 Pages
TPD FISCHER INTERVIEW_BK2P328_4PP
WASHINGTON STATE PATROL
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION DIVISION
Investigative Report
FILE TITLE David
Brame
DETECTIVE Sergeant Michael B. Haw
CASE NUMBER 03-004969
SUBJECT David Fischer Interview.
SYNOPSIS:
On October 3, 2003, Washington State Patrol (WSP) Detective Sergeant
Michael B. Haw and WSP Lieutenant Grant Hulteen interviewed Tacoma
Police Department (TPD) Officer David Fischer. Fischer provided
information regarding a domestic violence incident involving David
and Crystal Brame, and Fischer's subsequent phone conversation with
Crystal the same evening. The interview was not tape-recorded. <?>
DETAILS:
1996 Domestic Violence Incident
On October 3, 2003, Washington State Patrol (WSP) Detective Sergeant
Michael B. Haw and WSP Lieutenant Grant Hulteen interviewed Tacoma
Police Department (TPD) Officer David Fischer. Fischer was
interviewed subsequent to a letter Fischer sent to WSP Criminal
Investigation Division Commander Captain Brian Ursino (dated May 21,
2003) in which Fischer described an incident involving David and
Crystal Brame which occurred in 1996.1
Fischer said he has been Police Patrol Officer (PPO) with TPD for
fifteen years, and was assigned as an acting sergeant approximately
eighty-percent of the period between April 1994 and January 1997.
Fischer stated that sometime in 1996, but prior to December of that
year, (Fischer could not recall the specific date) he was assigned as
a temporary or acting sergeant with TPD, working the
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 2 of 4
graveyard shift.2 Fischer said he was contacted by the
communications center <?> and advised Crystal Brame had made a 911
call regarding a domestic dispute involving herself and her husband,
David Brame. Fischer said he called the Brame residence and contacted
Crystal, who was, ".. .almost hysterical". According to Fischer.
Crystal was crying, and advised Fischer that she just had a big
argument with David Brame, although Fischer could not recall <?> what
the argument was about, he thought it was about something minor. <?>
Fisher said he asked Crystal if David had physically assaulted her,
and she stated he had not. Fischer also asked Crystal if David had
threatened her and she denied this. Fischer stated Crystal told him
David had left the house with his weapons, and Fisher asked Crystal
if Brame had made threats to harm himself, and Crystal stated he had
not, and that she did not know what he [Brame] was going to do.
According to Fischer, Crystal said David Brame might have gone to his
parent's house.Fischer stated he believed at the time that Brame had
perhaps taken his weapons to separate them from Crystal, or maybe
Brame planned to spend the night elsewhere, in which case Brame would
need the weapons for work the next day. Fischer said Crystal seemed
very upset that Brame had taken the weapons.
Fischer said he advised Crystal he was going to have a Gig Harbor <?>
Police officer contact her residence to check on her and told her to
be sure to open the door so the officer could be sure she was not
injured. Although Fischer believed a Gig Harbor Police officer had
already been to the residence, he was not positive they had made
contact with Crystal. Fischer stated that although Crystal was
reluctant to talk to a responding Gig Harbor officer, he was "pretty
sure" Crystal agreed to talk to him/her if an officer responded.
Fischer stated Crystal told him several times not to tell anyone
about her calling 911 because she did not want to get David Brame in
any trouble at work.
Fischer said he gave Crystal his cell phone number, and told her to
call him if David Brame returned to the residence. Fischer stated he
probably kept detailed notes in his notebook of his conversations
with Crystal and Woodard; he was unable to locate the notebook.<?>
Fischer said that after he terminated the call to Crystal, he
immediately called the night shift duty lieutenant, Catherine Woodard
and advised her of the previously described scenario. Fischer said
Woodard responded with either, "I'll handle it" or, "I'll take care
of it." Fischer stated he then asked Woodard if she wanted him to
write a report regarding the incident and/or drive to Brame's
parent's house and check on Brame. According to Fischer, Woodard
responded negatively to both options.
Fischer said he did not tell anyone about the incident,<?> and never
heard anything about how the issue between David and Crystal Brame
was resolved. Because Fischer never heard anything else about the
issue, he assumed there had been no physical altercation between the
Brame's.
_____________________
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 3 of 4
Captain William Meeks alleged Hat Theft
When asked about his knowledge of the allegation against Captain
William Meeks regarding the theft of baseball hats during a warrant
service, Fischer stated that it was common knowledge in TPD that
Meeks collected baseball hats. After Meeks was accused of the theft,
the common perception within the department was that Brame could not
possibly promote Meeks beyond the rank of captain, and that Meeks'
career was now at a "Dead end".
Fischer stated everyone knew Brame and Meeks were close friends, and
that he [Fischer] now believed Brame knew he was going to kill
himself because he promoted Meeks to assistant chief a week before he
killed himself.3
Promotional Issues
During the interview, Fischer stated he was concerned that David
Brame had found his cell phone number which Crystal had written down,
or otherwise learned about his involvement in Brame's 1996 domestic
violence incident and would hold a grudge against him. Although
Fischer stated he was unaware of the depth of Woodard and Brame's
relationship in 1996, but when he learned of the incident involving
Brame and Woodard contacting the Lane and Patty Judsen residence in
Canterwood, he believed Brame and Woodard could have conspired to
prevent him from being promoted to sergeant.
Fischer said that in December of 1996, when Fischer was first on the
sergeant's list, Woodard asked him, "How would you feel if you were
passed up?" Fischer stated he responded, "I'd probably file a
grievance because I have much more experience as an acting sergeant,
received excellent evaluations while serving in that position, and
was next on the list." According to Fischer, Woodard reacted in a
surprised manner.
Fischer stated that in 1997, after he was passed up for promotion to
sergeant, he contacted the Local 6 leadership to discuss the
possibility of filing a grievance. The Local 6 president and vice
president were Robert Blystone and David Brame, respectively.
According to Fischer, Brame and Blystone advised him his grievance
would be difficult to prove, and the union executive board voted not
to provide representation to Fischer. Fischer stated he filed an
appeal with the Civil Service Board and represented himself, and the
Board eventually decided they had no jurisdiction in Fischer's case;
Fischer stated he sent letters to City Manager Ray Corpuz and the
City Council members, to no avail.
Fischer said that when Brame was a lieutenant, everyone in TPD knew
he was being groomed for
Investigative
Report
Case Number: 03-004969
Sergeant Michael B. Haw
Page 4 of 4
the chiefs position. According to Fischer, "Brame knew that I knew"
[Referring to Brame's 1996 domestic incident with Crystal], but Brame
never said anything to Fischer about the incident. Fischer said that
Brame once approached him and stated, "We're getting a new board
member," Fischer asked for clarification and Brame replied, "There's
nothing better that an employee scorned." [Referring to Fischer's
grievance]
1 See Addendum AK, Fischer's letter to Ursino.
2 This incident could be the same as the one described in Detective
Norm Conaway's and David Brame's notes documenting the alleged
domestic violence which occurred on September 28, 1996.
3 Brame promoted Meeks on Monday, April 21, 2003, and on Friday,
April 26, 2003, Brame killed Crystal and himself.
4. In December 1996, Fischer held the top position on the sergeant's
list which was due to expire in January of 1997. Sergeant Catherine
McCalpine was promoted instead of Fischer, even though she was behind
Fischer on the list and had much less experience as an acting
sergeant.___________________________________________________
RECEIVED MAY 28 2003 WSP - CID FIQ
05-21-03
David Fischer
Police Patrol Officer
Tacoma Police Dept.
930 Tacoma Ave.
Tacoma, WA 98402
(253) 573-****
Captain Brian Ursino
Washington State Patrol
PO 'Box 42600
Olympia, WA 98504
RE: Criminal Investigation / David Brame
Dear Captain Ursino,
I am writing this statement in regards to some information that I
have regarding the investigation of David Brame. No one has ever
contacted me regarding this incident so I just wanted to be sure that
you have all the information that I have knowledge of for your
investigation into the Brame case.
I have tried to determine when this incident occurred, but I am
unable to find any information or date of occurrence for this
incident. I believe it occurred some time in 1996 while I was working
for the Tacoma Police Department as a Temporary and/or Acting
Sergeant on the graveyard shift.
I received a call from LESA dispatch that there was a (911) call of a
domestic dispute from Crystal Brame at their Gig Harbor home. I
believe the Gig Harbor Police responded to the Brame's residence, but
they were unable to contact anyone? I got the Brame residence's phone
number from dispatch and called the residence.
Crystal Brame answered the phone and she sounded like she was upset
and crying. I told her who I was, and that I was calling regarding
the (911) call she had made. Crystal said she and David had gotten
into an argument, but I don't recall what, or if she said what the
argument was about. I asked her if she was okay, and if there was a
physical altercation between her and David. She said she was okay,
and that they just had an argument. She sounded very upset so I again
asked her if any kind of physical violence or assault had occurred.
Crystal again said that they had only argued and nothing else
occurred.
I asked her where David was, and she said he had left. She said she
was scared because he took his guns with him when he left. Crystal
said David did not make any kind of threats to her or himself, but
she was worried that he had taken his guns with him. I asked her if
she knew where David had gone. Crystal said she wasn't sure, but she
thought he might have went to his parent's house for the night.
Crystal said two or three times during the conversation, that she was
sorry and she didn't want to get David in any trouble at work. She
also asked me not to tell anyone that she had called because she
didn't want to get David into any trouble. I asked her why she
thought she would get him in trouble if all they did was have an
argument. She said she didn't know, but she knew David would be mad
at her if he knew she had called.
I told Crystal that I was going to have a Gig Harbor Police Officer
come to her house just to check on her and make sure she was okay. I
told her that an officer needed to contact her in person to make sure
she was okay, and that she needed to tell him what had happened.
Crystal agreed to cooperate and talk with the officer when he got to
her residence. I gave Crystal my name and department cellular phone
number, and I told her to call me if she needed anything else, or to
call (911) if it was an emergency.
I then called dispatch by phone and told them to send a Gig Harbor
Police officer to the Brame residence to contact Crystal and verify
that she was okay, and that there were no signs of injuries or a
physical domestic violence incident.
Immediately after hanging up with dispatch, I called the on-duty
night shift lieutenant who was Lt. Catherine (Crews) Woodard. I told
her exactly what had happened and what Crystal Brame had told me. I
also told Woodard that I had told dispatch to send a Gig Harbor
Police officer over to check on Crystal to make sure she was okay,
and to check for any sign of a physical domestic violence incident. I
told Woodard that David had left his residence and had taken his guns
with him. I told Woodard that Crystal thought David might be going to
stay the night at his parent's residence.
After telling Woodard everything that Crystal had told me, Woodard
thanked me for telling her about the incident. I told her everything
that I had done, and asked her if there was anything else she wanted
me to do (write a report, or check on David or Crystal)? Woodard
said, no and that she would handle it.
I never heard anything about the incident after talking to Woodard
that night, not from her or anyone else. I assumed that Woodard had
followed up on the incident and determined that it was just a verbal
dispute between Crystal and David, as Crystal had told me.
Prior to this incident, I was not aware of any domestic problems
between David and Crystal Brame. I was also not aware that the
Brame's were having domestic or marital problems at any time after
this incident up until the day after David shot and killed his wife
and himself.
I was also not aware that Catherine Woodard was a good friend of
David Brame's until after the Brame's deaths.
Now that I know that Catherine Woodard and David Brame were such
close friends (as Woodard herself has stated), and now that I know
that the Brame's had been having marital and domestic violence
problems, I believe I may have been "black balled" by Woodard and
David Brame as a result of my knowledge and handling of the Brame
domestic dispute back in 1996. I also do not know if Woodard ever
reported the incident between the Brames that I informed her about,
or if she had covered for David Brame by not reporting it to anyone
or following up on the incident with the Gig Harbor Police Department.
As I stated, I was working as a Temporary Sergeant in 1996 at the
time of this incident. Near the end of 1996 there was a permanent
Sergeant position opening, and I was number (1) on the Sergeant's
list at that time. I had been working as an Acting and Temporary
Sergeant for about (2) and a half years. All of my Sergeant's
probationary reports during that time stated that I was doing an
excellent job as a Sergeant. I also had far more experience as a
Sergeant than the other officers ranked behind me on the Sergeant's
list. Yet despite being ranked number (1) on the list, and all of the
experience as a Sergeant I had, and all of the excellent ratings I
received on my Sergeant probationary reports, I was passed over for
the permanent Sergeant's position. Instead, they promoted another
officer ranked number (2) on the Sergeant's list, who had far less
experience as a Sergeant than I had. The Sergeant's list expired a
few weeks later and I never made permanent Sergeant.
At the time that I was passed over for the promotion I assumed that I
was passed over because they wanted to promote a female to the
position, and I subsequently filed a grievance and appeal on the
basis of discrimination. However, after learning what I now know
about the Brame's domestic problems, and Catherine Woodard's
involvement and close friendship with David Brame, I believe that I
was intentionally passed over for promotion because I was "black
balled" by the administration, specifically by Brame and Woodard.
I recall an incident just prior to my rule of three interview for the
Sergeant's position, in which Catherine Woodard approached me and
asked me what I would do if I didn't get the promotion. I asked her
how could I not get the promotion since I was ranked number (1) on
the Sergeant's list, had extensive experience as a Sergeant, and my
high ratings on my Sergeant's probationary reports? Woodard said, you
just never know, anything can happen. She then again asked me what I
would do if it did happen, and I didn't get promoted. I told her I
probably would file a grievance or appeal. She asked me what would I
have to file a grievance about. I again explained to her, based on my
ranking on the Sergeant's list, experience compared to the other
candidates, and my excellent ratings on my Sergeant's probationary
reports, that I was the best qualified candidate for the position.
I thought it was odd that Woodard would ask me these questions at the
time. Now, in light of everything that has happened regarding the
Brame incident, and Woodard's involvement and close friendship with
David Brame, I believe that David Brame and Catherine Woodard used
their positions in the administration to influence the decision of
the promotion in which I was passed over for. I believe they abused
their positions of authority and had me passed over for promotion to
Sergeant because of that incident in which I had talked to Crystal
Brame about the domestic dispute between her and David.
Again, I can not recall the exact date of this incident, but the Gig
Harbor Police Department may have a record of the date of the
incident, and possibly more information on what Crystal Brame may
have told the officer that contacted her that night.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions or if
you need any further information from me.
Also, please forward this information to any other agency that is
involved with the investigation of this incident such as the
Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs, Office of the
Attorney General, FBI, and any other agency involved.
Thank you. Sincerely,
David Fischer
Tacoma Police Department, PPO
It's not over til' the truth is fully known.