Discussion:
The right way to reduplicate information in a sentence?
(too old to reply)
Dingbat
2019-11-29 00:43:55 UTC
Permalink
The right way to reduplicate information in a sentence?

This sentence twice gives the information that Peggy was the only female
in this workforce. The wording looks jarring.

It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she was.
https://www.bobshideout.com/view/husbands-disappearance-revealed/?page=6

I'd find it perfectly acceptable with one word added:

It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she INDEED was.

As to why INDEED should make such a difference, I'm at a loss to explain.
Can someone explain it, if they agree that INDEED does indeed make the
sentence acceptable?
Peter Moylan
2019-11-29 01:03:32 UTC
Permalink
Post by Dingbat
The right way to reduplicate information in a sentence?
This sentence twice gives the information that Peggy was the only female
in this workforce. The wording looks jarring.
It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she was.
https://www.bobshideout.com/view/husbands-disappearance-revealed/?page=6
It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she INDEED was.
As to why INDEED should make such a difference, I'm at a loss to explain.
Can someone explain it, if they agree that INDEED does indeed make the
sentence acceptable?
I don't see anything unacceptable about the original.
--
Peter Moylan http://www.pmoylan.org
Newcastle, NSW, Australia
Athel Cornish-Bowden
2019-11-29 07:37:28 UTC
Permalink
Post by Peter Moylan
Post by Dingbat
The right way to reduplicate information in a sentence?
This sentence twice gives the information that Peggy was the only female
in this workforce. The wording looks jarring.
It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she was.
https://www.bobshideout.com/view/husbands-disappearance-revealed/?page=6
It wasn't that Peggy was the only woman mechanic working at the Altus
Oklahoma Air Force Base, although she INDEED was.
As to why INDEED should make such a difference, I'm at a loss to explain.
Can someone explain it, if they agree that INDEED does indeed make the
sentence acceptable?
I don't see anything unacceptable about the original.
I agree. I don't think "indeed" helps.
--
athel
Loading...