malcolm
2006-01-10 20:14:10 UTC
I recently heard a live performance of the Rachmaninov 3rd that is,
hands down, the best performance I have ever heard. The surprise is
that the pianist is Alicia De Larrocha, from a 1972 live performance at
Carnegie Hall (Andre Previn leading the LSO).
For those that are only familiar with her studio account (which is
wonderful, but a bit subdued), this one is infinitely better. Frankly,
as great an admirer of this pianist as I am, even I was a bit surpised
that she had it in her to deliver a performance that is so
interpretively and technically on target as this one. From a purely
technical perspective, it is easily the equal of Argerich's much
praised account, but more controlled. And interpretively, it surpasses
it (as well as just about any other recording I've ever heard). (I had
much the same reaction to a live performance by her of #2, but the
sound on that one was pretty bad).
In theory it may seem impossible for a woman as tiny as she is to be
capable of such playing, but hearing is believing.
Malcolm
hands down, the best performance I have ever heard. The surprise is
that the pianist is Alicia De Larrocha, from a 1972 live performance at
Carnegie Hall (Andre Previn leading the LSO).
For those that are only familiar with her studio account (which is
wonderful, but a bit subdued), this one is infinitely better. Frankly,
as great an admirer of this pianist as I am, even I was a bit surpised
that she had it in her to deliver a performance that is so
interpretively and technically on target as this one. From a purely
technical perspective, it is easily the equal of Argerich's much
praised account, but more controlled. And interpretively, it surpasses
it (as well as just about any other recording I've ever heard). (I had
much the same reaction to a live performance by her of #2, but the
sound on that one was pretty bad).
In theory it may seem impossible for a woman as tiny as she is to be
capable of such playing, but hearing is believing.
Malcolm