bpnjensen
2006-05-03 16:36:04 UTC
Hi, all.
Every composer who has written symphonies, somewhere along the line,
wrote a first one. Is there a consensus on which first symphony by any
composer stands out as the best of its primary class, perhaps even a
bonafide masterpiece? Beethoven, Brahms, Elgar? Would it be a product
of youthful inspiration, or the work of a seasoned composer who waited
until he/she felt that the time was truly ripe for an attack on this
musical form?
Vaughan-Williams, in my mind, gets a lot right in his Symphony No. 1 "A
Sea Symphony" - it has tremendous power, unflagging interest (which to
my mind means, in part, pretty good construction) and a fine lot of
melody. Very satisfying, and I believe a contender (although I admit a
really fond spot for V-W in general and his symphonies in particular -
when I hear his music, it sounds like a special present, composed just
for me, by a dear friend). Any other thoughts?
Bruce Jensen
Every composer who has written symphonies, somewhere along the line,
wrote a first one. Is there a consensus on which first symphony by any
composer stands out as the best of its primary class, perhaps even a
bonafide masterpiece? Beethoven, Brahms, Elgar? Would it be a product
of youthful inspiration, or the work of a seasoned composer who waited
until he/she felt that the time was truly ripe for an attack on this
musical form?
Vaughan-Williams, in my mind, gets a lot right in his Symphony No. 1 "A
Sea Symphony" - it has tremendous power, unflagging interest (which to
my mind means, in part, pretty good construction) and a fine lot of
melody. Very satisfying, and I believe a contender (although I admit a
really fond spot for V-W in general and his symphonies in particular -
when I hear his music, it sounds like a special present, composed just
for me, by a dear friend). Any other thoughts?
Bruce Jensen