Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechI'm straight about it, but you may have gotten something wrong from
what I said. Separately meant that it was coming in without the family
and all the agents, which would hinder them in doing the things they were
ordered to do.
So by that definition, when they dropped Jackie off at the front and then
drove the body around to the back, that means the body came in separately.
The body in the SHIPPING casket came to the morgue at least 42 minutes
before the Bronze casket which was with the family (including Jackie) and
the various agents in a motorcade from the airport. Based on sworn
testimony and documents.
Complete fabrication. Even if we were to except your bogus scenario (which
I most certainly do not), your timeline doesn't show a 42 minute
difference in arrival times.
So then you're calling me a liar! fabrications are lies! You're
saying that the sworn testimony and the documents that I've shown are
lies. But of course, you have proof that the documents are false and that
everything I've said above was a lie. Tell me how you know that? Your
opinion as usual?
Other than Boyajian's after action report which specified a casket
arriving at 6:35, what document shows any other casket arriving at the
loading dock.
When I said "document" I meant the Boyajian after action report.
However, we could also include the report by the Gawler's crew which
states as follows:
"Body removed from metal shipping casket at USNH at Beth."
From: http://educationforum.ipbhost.com/topic/21048-edwin-stroble-prepared-john-f-kennedy-for-funeral/
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogA casket was logged as arriving at 6:35.
There is no other log indicating a second casket.
WRONG! The log from Gawler's which I linked to just above mentions
another casket called a "Marcellus 710" which they brought with them, and
of course, the SHIPPING casket which they saw the body come out of. You
don't seem to be familiar with these things. How's the old memory?
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechWRONG! Your favorite witness Richard Lipsey said clearly that there
would be a casket with the BODY in it that would arrive at the back door
(morgue). I showed you the interview of Dennis David and the after action
report of Sgt. Boyajian and you're going to call them liars too? The old
LN whine...they all lied! You have to be fried if you think all the sworn
testimony and documents are wrong! Paranoia to the max! David identified
the casket and a SHIPPING casket. Edward Reed helped bring in the
SHIPPING casket and saw that it was JFK inside when it was opened.
Everything fits, and you sit there and pretend that they all lied and the
documents are phony, etc.
No, I'm trying to get you to cite a document that there was a second
casket arrival.
I've just done that above. And why there would be a "document" that
said that I don't know. Probably you clinging to a dying hope.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechThen you've also seen the testimony of Dennis David when a half hour
later he saw the second ambulance at the main entrance letting off the
family to go upstairs on the elevator. Not once have you been able to
shake the eyewitness accounts of these people, yet you blat out you
opinion that opposes everything with no proof at all! Talk about denial!
The eyewitness accounts are contradictory. I go with the witnesses whose
accounts fit with other known facts.
There are no "contradictions" if you understand what happened.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogSibert's later
recollection was that the body was already being prepared for autopsy by
7:17.
WRONG! The process BEGAN at 7:17pm he said. But then why was the
first cut recorded by the FBI as 8:15pm? Is your witness any good? That
leaves an hour with everyone just sitting around. They must have been
waiting for the high level officers and 'guests' to arrive.
You should be asking yourself these questions. You are the one trying to
use Sibert to establish a second casket arriving at 7:17 which is
ludicrous because he didn't say a casket was delivered at 7:17.
This has all been discussed thoroughly, but you will pretend you forgot
it all. Here's some info:
"The motorcade arrived at the front of the NNMC at 6:55 PM [4, p. 478].
Hence, that is when Sibert and O’Neill arrived. Their report
states that, after Mrs. Kennedy and Robert Kennedy had alighted and
entered the building, the ambulance (carrying the Dallas casket)
“was thereafter driven to the rear entrance...” The word
“thereafter” is a catch-all, concealing a significant
delay before the navy ambulance moved to the rear [4, p. 478].
After the delay, Sibert and O’Neill either drove or walked [2, p.
43] to the loading dock adjacent to the morgue complex and arrived there
presumably at 7:17 PM, the time they gave to Arlen Specter for when
“preparation of the autopsy” began [8, p. 2]. This begs
the question of what happened between 7:17 and 8:15 PM, the time they gave
for when the "first incision was made." Nothing in their report directly
answers this question, and, we believe, for good reason, i.e. they needed
to conceal the fact that they failed in their primary duty: they lost
vigil of the president’s body/casket for a considerable period of
time."
From: http://www.manuscriptservice.com/JWS-FXO/
Post by bigdogNobody
said that and no document said that, yet you treat it as an established
fact that a second casket arrived at 7:17. Sibert was the only one who
mentioned 7:17 and he didn't use that to specify the time of arrival. It
is a complete factoid that there was a casket which arrived at 7:17, aka a
fabrication.
The fabrication is yours, since you refuse to put all the facts
together and prove to yourself that there was a second casket. Now here's
yet another document showing that there was a second and a third casket:
http://educationforum.ipbhost.com/topic/20138-photo-or-layout-of-bethesda-autopsy-room/
Note that the drawing shows the movement of the SHIPPING casket coming
in from the loading dock to the right by the table #1. Next you see the
movement of the body from table #1 to table #2 for embalming. Next, you
se the cooler room where Sibert said he put the Bronze casket. Later
Custer put in the heavy dark marker casket, which was the Marcellus 710
that the Gawler's people brought. This is yet another proof that there
were 3 caskets, which included the SHIPPING casket and the Bronze casket.
But it won't matter how much proof I show, and I've shown a lot. You
will bow to your faith in the WCR and disbelieve all evidence except the
WCR.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogThat doesn't establish what time the ornamental casket arrived since
you are claiming that casket was empty. There is no document showing a
second casket arrival at 7:17 or any other time. If a second casket
arrived, why do you suppose Sgt. Boyajian didn't log that one as well?
Apparently Boyajian wasn't part of the second or third process.
"In this author's opinion, the information provided above is proof beyond
a reasonable doubt that President Kennedy's body arrived at the Bethesda
morgue at shortly after 6:30 PM in a shipping casket. The ornamental
casket, in which the body had been placed in Dallas, arrived at Bethesda
Naval Hospital at 6:55 PM, and was carried into the morgue twice.
Initially this occurred at approximately 7:17 PM with the casket carried
by FBI Special Agents James Sibert and Francis O'Neill and Secret Service
agents into the anteroom, and it occurred again at 8:00 PM with the casket
carried by the honor guard into the morgue."
From: http://www.manuscriptservice.com/BNH-chicanery/
So if you are not using Boyajian's report to establish a second casket
arrival at 7:17, what is your source for a second casket arriving AT THAT
TIME?
You can read. See above. James Sibert's various comments as to time
will suffice. He stated he brought in the Bronze casket and placed in in
the cooler room, exactly as the drawing shows. We've been over this a
number of times, why are you forcing us to repeat it all over again?
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechAt the above link you can find the names of all the servicemen that
were part of the casket situation, for each of the 3 'arrivals'.
Hopefully, this will be remembered by you so that this is not necessary
to go through again.
According to your above link, the Navy ambulance arrived at Bethesda at
about 6:55, not 7:17 as you keep insisting.
WRONG as usual! What is wrong with you? It should be clear to you by
now that the arrival of 6:55pm was for the ambulance (with the empty
casket) to arrive at the main entrance of the Bethesda hospital. They
then let off the family who then went up in the elevator to the 17th floor
to the VIP suite. They then drove around to the back of the building
where the loading dock for the morgue was located. By then it was 7:17pm.
They brought in the Bronze casket and had to put it in the cooler room
because the SHIPPING casket was in the morgue next to table #1 and the
Gawler's casket was there on the floor, so there was no room for the
Bronze casket that came from Parkland.
Post by bigdogDo you even bother to read the
articles you provide links to? You have no source for a casket arriving at
7:17 so why do you keep claiming that happened? Why do you object when I
call that a fabrication?
I don't like being called a liar when it's not true. I have given you
all the information needed to KNOW that the Bronze casket arrived at the
morgue at about 7:17pm and 42 minutes later than the SHIPPING casket with
the body in it. Your inability to use simple understanding is very
irritating. This is all old news that you failed to understand the first
few times we went through it. I'm getting to the point that you just
don't have the capacity to take on this information, since your minds
which is besotted by the WCR must be rejecting anything other than the
WCR.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechSo you're making up things I said once
again! My point was that they knew that there would be an arrival of the
body at that time, so they were waiting on the loading dock. The only way
that could happen is by Humes getting a phone call.
I'm sure they were told the body was arriving shortly. I'm trying to
figure out why you think that is an indication the body was arriving in a
different casket than the one that was in the Navy ambulance.
You're off on a wild goose chase. You need anything to try and
pretend that my information is somehow faulty.
I don't need to pretend that.
Post by mainframetechThe explanation is above
for the separately comment.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechThe information that the body was sent over from the airport by
helicopter was discussed on the AF1 plane,
It was discussed and ultimately decide to drive the body to Bethesda by
Navy ambulance.
And yet the body arrived 42 minutes before the Bronze casket.
Where's your logic hat?
That didn't happen. That is just your FUBAR figuring.
Nope. Won't do. You've had all the backup and proof needed to know
that the body arrived in a different casket. We've discussed it to death
and I've proved my point over and over. If you've forgotten again, that's
too bad. I remind you of Dennis David who helped carry in the body to the
morgue from the ambulance. He later (half hour) went to a mezzanine where
he saw the second ambulance arrive at the main entrance and the family
come out of it and go up in the elevator to the 17th floor to the VIP
suite. The ambulance then went around the back of the building which was
the location of the morgue, and the agents got out.
How could he see the main entrance from the mezzanine?
I use the term as a 'balcony' type area that stands over the main
entrance. It would overlook the lobby that is part of the main entrance.
How could he observe both those events from that location?
Now what are you talking about? Don't you know what a balcony is?
That it can overhang a lobby which has a main entrance to a hospital?
None of this is new.
You are citing David as seeing the ambulance stop at the front entrance
and also seeing the ambulance drive up to the loading dock. I'm wondering
where he could have been that would have allowed him to see both events.
Lordee! You just refuse to face the fact that the 2 arrivals were
many minutes apart. Dennis David was able to se both arrivals because he
was in charge of the detail that brought in the SHIPPING casket and then
he went to a location where he could see the main entrance and he then saw
the Bronze casket ambulance arrive at the main entrance. Simple.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechand there was logically no
choice that a helicopter was used because the body arrived 42 minutes
before the empty Bronze casket. So you're wrong again, and the proof is
there.
Pure nonsense. The body arrived by Navy ambulance in the same casket it
was placed in at Parkland and which Siebert and O'Neill saw removed from
AT THE START of the autopsy proceedings.
WRONG! You've been showed the testimony of the men that took the body
out of the SHIPPING casket and recognized JFK, and that was just after
6:35pm. The Bronze casket didn't arrive at the morgue until at least
7:17pm. And we've had this whole discussion many times, so kindly stop
repeating the whole thing.
Wrong on all counts. The body arrived at 6:35 in the bronze casket. That
is the time it was logged in at the loading dock. The only reference to
7:17 was a Sibert and O'Neill report which said that was the time they
began preparations for the autopsy. Nobody said a casket arrived at the
loading dock at 7:17. Nobody except you.
We've been all over all this. Why is your brain so fogged up that you
can't remember a single thing? You've been shown the statements and
testimony of the men that brought in the SHIPPING casket and they
identified it as such, and they then recognized JFK in that casket.
You've been shown the statements where Sibert and O'Neill said the body
was removed from the casket that they had accompanied from Andrews but you
reject that.
I DO NOT REJECT THAT. All that was explained to you, but apparently
it was just too complicated for you to grasp. I'll try again in simple
words. There were 3 casket arrivals that night. First was the SHIPPING
casket at about 6:35pm. Then the Bronze casket at about 7:17pm.
Why do you keep saying that when you know no witness or document shows a
casket arriving at 7:17. That has been pointed out to you countless times
and still you pretend not to know that. 7:17 was the time Sibert said they
began preparations for the autopsy. That was not the time of arrival of
any casket. There is no witness or document that supports a casket
arriving at 7:17.
See above. I've showed you that info before but your crazed mind was
unable to contain the info.
You have NEVER cited a document or a witness who said a casket arrived at
7:17 yet you continue to insist that happened. No such document or witness
exists and we both know it.
Bull! Sibert was that witness. He didn't have to say what you want
to hear to make it plain that it's what he meant from what he DISD say.
What's the matter with you? The time of 7:17pm came from Sibert. And the
other times came from each place that I quoted. The ambulance arrived at
the main entrance at 6:55pm, and that fits with an arrival at 7:17pm at
the morgue around back.
You're not going to get away and escape the fact that there were
multiple caskets or that there was switch and the facts prove it.
Post by bigdogPost by mainframetechPost by bigdogPost by mainframetechThen the
one you need to know about last, which was the bronze casket with the body
in it. When that casket was opened, the agents saw the body of JFK inside
and they may have even helped get the body onto the morgue table.
This tale of yours gets more ludicrous the hard you try to save it. Lifton
and Horne only have two caskets arriving.
Correct for a change! There were 2 caskets. The SHIPPING casket and the
Bronze casket. But the Bronze casket arrived twice. And the tale is not
http://www.manuscriptservice.com/BNH-chicanery/
So we have Boyajian's estimate of a casket arriving at 6:35, David saying
it arrived about 6:45 and Reed saying it had already arrived when he got
there at 6:30.
Chalk up another WRONG! You mind just isn't up to handling this fairly
simple process. You won't listen and you keep insisting silly things. I
would trust Boyajian's timing more than David's, since he seems more
squared away. Same for Reed.
Post by bigdogSo should we believe that these were three different casket
arrivals or that these three men simply gave varying estimates of the time
of the same casket arrival.
Don't be ridiculous. It's amazing! I could use this sequence of events
as an IQ test. Pass it and you're average intelligence. Fail and it's
time for special training. The story of Dennis David, who saw BOTH casket
arrivals proves that idea is stupid. And he knew the difference in the
type of caskets that were involved.
Post by bigdogNow we get to your real source for a 7:17 arrival. It doesn't come from
any witness nor from any document. He comes from the author of the article
you have cited. He admitted as much when he wrote, This author estimates
that Sibert and O'Neill, along with Greer and the ambulance, arrived at
the morgue entrance just prior to 7:17 PM. Sibert told the ARRB that he
and O'Neill assisted Greer and Kellerman in taking the ornamental bronze
casket into the anteroom of the morgue at about 7:17 PM [15, p. 45; p.
50]. In their interview with Specter, both agents said that "preparations
for the autopsy" occurred at approximately 7:17 PM [12, p. 2]. "
So there we have it. No witness said 7:17. No document said 7:17. Just
some kook author whom you have placed blind faith in. The silliness stems
from believing that differences in the estimated time of arrival of a
casket indicates there were multiple casket arrivals rather than simply
that the men making the estimates differed in their estimates.
You've screwed up badly. Your constant failure to understand the
situation and to listen to what your being told is just plain foolish.
You're WRONG again, and I see that you'll never get it right. I'm not
doing any of this for you, but to make it clear to others that may listen
in. By now, I' sure THEY know what the story is, so you failing yet again
isn't important. But I'm done wasting my time on you. I'm outa here.
Chris